Dr. Andy

Reflections on medicine and biology among other things

Wednesday, May 04, 2005

Marijuana, Schizophrenia and Reefer Madness

The government is going after marijuana because, they claim, it may lead to serious mental health problmes:
Youngsters who use marijuana are more likely to develop serious mental health problems, the government said Tuesday. . . .But questions remain about whether people who smoke marijuana at a young age are already predisposed to mental disorders, or whether the drug caused those disorders
My initial reaction is great skepticism; my general sense is that the anti-drug establishment is cavalier with its claims of harm, particularly from marijuana (I am not a regular user of any illegal drugs, so I don't have a particular axe to grind; I do use alcohol and caffeine regularly) which I generally regard as on par with alcohol as far as safety and probably better than tobacco. As I'm generally libertarian, I have been in favor of marijuana decrimilization, but it is not a big issue for me*.

But I remembered an interesting article (not free except subscribers, I think) I saw about the issue that swayed me a bit. Published in BMJ this January, it involves nearly 2500 Germans age 14-24. Predispositon to psychosis and marijuana use were measured at baseline and then development of psychosis and current marijuana use were measured four years later.

As had been shown in other studies, pot use increased the risk of psychosis. But it is always hard to know whether this represents an effect of the marijuana or just self-treatment by those predisposed to psychosis. In other words, people who are going to be psychotic may already have mild, sub-clinical symptoms and use marijuana to treat them.

What made this study better and more convincing was that they showed that the increased risk from marijuana use was much higher in those predisposed to psychosis. That is, those identified at "high risk" at baseline who smoked pot had a greatly increased risk of psychosis compared to those at risk who didn't. Those not identified at risk had only a small increase. Further, the "at risk" assesment at baseline did not predict use of marijuana at follow up, which argues against the self-medicating hypothesis. Not conclusive, but suggestive. The article also discusses colocalization of cannibis and dopamine receptors in the brain (dopamine is dysregulated in schizophrenia and other psychoses).

Legalization advocates criticize this and similar studies as association, not causation and on a variety of other grounds. I can't help but feel, that, in reverse of the usual situation, it is the pro-marijuana argument that relies on distortion and half-truths in this case

Now as the original article points out, whether a slightly increased risk of schizoprhenia justifies all the social costs of the war on marijuana is still an open question


*It occurr to me than marijuana decrimilization/legalization faces a significant problem: those who smoke regularly are unlikely to have the energy and initiative to effectively advocate for legalization and those (like me) who don't smoke but are in principle are in favor are unlikely to care enought about the issue to do so.

4 Comments:

At 2:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Andy,

I've been thinking about your asterisked comment on this topic for a while. I've been trying to figure out how to respond to it. Here is what you wrote:

"It occurr to me than marijuana decrimilization/legalization faces a significant problem: those who smoke regularly are unlikely to have the energy and initiative to effectively advocate for legalization and those (like me) who don't smoke but are in principle are in favor are unlikely to care enought about the issue to do so."

I can understand your position on the latter part of this, but I think there are reasons that all taxpayers should consider supporting and working towards legalization or decriminalization or at least decreased focus on enforcement.

I also believe that your generalization about users not having the "energy and intiative" might be missing something very significant. I think that these two things are tied together.

Our prison "industry" is exploding in this country and we have a huge number of non-violent drug offenders in jail. This employs a large number of people, and the taxpayers pay for it. That means you too. So, perhaps there is a financial incentive for you to think about working towards legalization or at least decriminalization.

There are also many casual users out there who hold jobs, have families, children, and other responsibilities in their lives. Many of those people are very scared about becoming part of the guest population of the prison industry - an industry not known for cushy accomodations, unless you're Martha Stewart or another connected corporate bigwig.

Why would those people voice opinions in public that are likely to catch the eye of the government or law enforcement? Why run the risk of losing a job, going to jail, and failing your family just so you can advocate in public something that isn't that difficult to obtain or use in private?

The prison industry wants to sustain itself and grow. The wholly corporate-owned government is glad to help out this big industry. The politicians currently in power get to pontificate on morals. They're all happy.

Perhaps, the people who you think might lack energy or intiative might simply just be afraid to go public with their opinions.

Maybe not, but I can think of a number of people who fall into that category.

 
At 9:04 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, i couldn't believe that a blog about marijuana could be so cool! Told be one that know a lot about marijuana as me.

 
At 11:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

We are the best of the best in Bongs with a beautiful accessories and we have the best service.
Be one of the ones that have the privilege to enjoy our Bongs.
we have all the ones that need to obtain not late more and contact us now.
Head Shop and Bong Amazing Legal Herbal Highs, featuring Herbal Smoke, Bongs,

 
At 8:39 PM, Blogger Omar Cruz said...

This page is fantastic, the infomation you show us is really interesting and is good written. Do you want to see something more? you can visit too: The marijuana care is an original annual plant of Asia,of diverse mountain ranges of the Himalaya.
Head Shop, Herbal Grinders
Bongs, Glass Pipe. Visit us for more info at: http://www.headshopinternational.com/

 

Post a Comment

<< Home